BABYMONSTER's debut single 'Batter Up' fails to hit a home run for YG Entertainment, drawing criticism for its lack of originality despite the diverse and talented lineup.
atter Up' represents a significant moment for YG Entertainment, promising to introduce the world to a new breed of K-pop girl group featuring members Ruka, Asa, Rora, Rami, Pharita, and Chiquita. This freshly launched group finds itself already engaging in a high-stakes performance, with their premiere release carrying the weight of the YG legacy, sculpted by the successes of acts like BIGBANG and BLACKPINK.
However, 'Batter Up' has swung into a field of mixed reactions rather than a clear home run. The single dives deep into YG's well of hip-hop influence, furnished with captivating hooks and powerful bass reminiscent of their acclaimed predecessors. The anticipation for BABYMONSTER has been building long before their debut, with YG aiming to ordain these newcomers as game changers in the global music market.
Despite the clear ambition and the showcase of strong rap abilities by members Ruka and Asa, 'Batter Up' faces criticism for treading too closely in the footsteps of 2NE1 and BLACKPINK. The production layout, MV themes, and overall song presentation bear a striking resemblance to prior YG works, particularly 'Boombayah.'
The song leans heavily on a YG house style that has become all too familiar and borders on self-parody, lacking novelty and delivering a predictably low-effort chorus. While there are some promising elements, the debut fails to captivate, despite the promising talent within the group.
BABYMONSTER's visuals reflect the youthful and confident energy of its members, albeit marred by comparisons. The song's message of confidence and determination is clear, yet the actual musical content lacks the necessary climax and distinct highlights to elevate it beyond mere adequacy.
'Batter Up' emerges as more of a bunt than a grand slam for BABYMONSTER and YG Entertainment. It demonstrates potential, especially in rap, but doesn't differentiate the group enough from its YG family, rendering the debut somewhat underwhelming. The group also doesn't seem to have found their chemistry. The success of BABYMONSTER will rely on how their subsequent releases address this swing-and-a-miss, and whether they can carve out a unique space in the heavy-hitting and saturated league of K-pop.
The multinational ensemble comprises of members of varied ages and nationalities: Japanese members Ruka, 21, and Asa, 17; Korean members Rami, 16, and Rora, 15; and Thai members Chiquita, the youngest at 14, and Pharita, 18.
PopFiltr is your personalized hub for in-depth music, media, and entertainment content, offering exclusive artist newsletters, insightful reviews, curated playlists, and comprehensive news and interviews.
